Engaged at the same time as your sibling? How to share the year
Two engagements in one family means twice the celebrating. It also means two sets of dates, guest lists and budgets landing on the same parents, aunties and friends, sometimes only months apart.
If that’s you, you’re in good company. Jodi RR Smith, of Mannersmith Etiquette Consulting and author of The Etiquette Book, says the situation is more common than you might think. There’s no rulebook to break, either.
Who picks a date first?
There’s no set order for sibling weddings. Jay Remer, an etiquette consultant known as The Etiquette Guy, says there’s no etiquette on the matter as such, and that common sense should prevail. Emily Lasnier, writing for Inside Weddings, adds that nobody can be expected to put their life on hold for someone else’s wedding.
Talking early helps. Emily suggests that if you set your date second, you check in with your sibling at each step. If you set yours first, she says it’s normal to feel a little irked by their plans now and then.
Spacing is where kindness comes in. “Kind and considerate siblings do try to space out their weddings,” Jodi says, for the guests’ sake and out of respect for the other couple.
Where many guests, or part of the wedding party, will be at both, Emily suggests leaving at least two to three months between them. If most guests live locally, the gap matters less.
Guests, parents and shared bridesmaids
Guests going to both weddings may be paying for two gifts, two trips and two lots of time off work. Emily suggests not assuming anything about anyone’s finances, and sending save-the-dates well ahead so people can plan for both.
If parents are helping with both weddings, ask them before either couple books a date. Emily suggests that if two peak-season weddings aren’t affordable, one in late spring and one in early autumn might ease the strain.
Fair doesn’t have to mean identical. AARP told the story of Susan Teague Sheehan, an American mother whose two sons married four months apart, with one wedding much pricier than the other. She chose to be equitable rather than equal, paying for the same things for each son, plus a generous wedding present.
Sisters Kat and Genevieve got engaged three days apart and married in the same year, sharing some of their bridesmaids. Writing for Spoken Bride, Genevieve suggests keeping costs light for friends in both bridal parties, for example by asking for nude shoes without naming a style. Both sisters recommend booking separate dress appointments, so each of you can shop properly and cheer the other on.
Two weddings, two personalities
Same season, same theme, same band. Emily says choices like these can cause friction, and that a booking is probably not worth damaging family relationships over.
Sharing suppliers has upsides too, and Kat and Genevieve used many of the same ones. Kat’s advice is to stay true to your own taste, even when your sister’s ideas are tempting.
Psychologist Dr Meredith Hansen suggests keeping the focus on planning together as a couple. The more you focus on your own relationship and wedding, she says, the less you’ll worry about the other one.
If you’d rather share the day itself, a double wedding is an option. Easy Weddings points out that guests coming to both only make one trip, and you can share a venue and photographer while keeping your own dress and cake. It also suggests plenty of planning and a rehearsal, and taking care the day doesn’t turn into a popularity contest.
However you split the year, there’s room for both of you. Do what feels right for your two families, and enjoy having someone who knows exactly what you’re going through.